• Featured
  • Australasia
  • The Americas
  • Europe
  • Africa
  • Market
  • Precious Metals
  • Resources
  • Currencies
  • Real Estate
  • The Bonner Diaries

Is the American Government the Place to Park Your Money During Dangerous Times?


By Nickolai Hubble • February 13th, 2010 • Related Articles • Filed Under

About the Author

Nickolai HubbleHaving recently escaped from academia, Nick decided to drop his tights (the required attire of a trapeze artist) and joined Port Phillip Publishing. Instead of telling everyone about the Daily Reckoning, he now spends his time writing for the weekend edition.

See All Articles by This Author

  • Price-to-Earnings Ratio of the S&P 500 Index
  • Gold is the Only Place to Turn in Times of Inflation
  • China Continuing to Buy US Bonds “Every Day”
  • Dividend Drop-Off: When Cushions Turn To Rocks
  • What Inflation Means to Central Bankers, Investors and the Consumer
Filed Under: Australasia • Market
Tags: Alex Cowie • American government • bernanke • buy and hold • fed • inflation • mining stocks • Nassim Taleb • stock markets • The Black Swan • U.S. dollar • U.S. Treasury • US government bonds

A Weak Week?

Stock markets around the world got the jitters, stumbled and then face planted. And that was just the first two days. Will the mud stick, or will the market get up and go-go-go from here on?

Why not ask Bill Bonner?

"We've had our bounce. Now, we'll take the long slide down to the ultimate, final, this-is-where-it-stops end."

Personally, I don't think sliding is quite the right word. Indexes don't slide around, they get pushed and shoved all over the place.

The strange thing about indices is that they only include the better performing companies. Most indicies have requirements for size or other factors before a company is included. If a company's share price falls enough, it is often deemed too small to be included in the index any longer. Thus, the underperformers aren't included in the index over time. The markets call this survivorship bias.

I call it fraud.

That's because the "buy and hold" strategy the mainstream advocates is based on index returns over time. Buying and holding a diversified portfolio won't necessarily get you the index returns, not that they are favourable in the first case.

If you diversify to the extent that the mainstream suggests, chances are that you will pick a lemon. It would only take one such lemon to make the whole portfolio sour. Meanwhile the index could happily continue on its way up, having dropped the lemon from its basket of companies.

Practice makes Perfect

We now know that world governments are perfectly comfortable with their "whatever it takes" attitude. Nobody else is. The humorous aspect to this is watching fund managers trying to work out where to park your/their money. Every country has a government willing to greet funds with open arms and an interest payment. More and more of those governments are in trouble though.

There has been much hype over ratings downgrades and increasing insurance costs on government bonds. What people are discovering is that there isn't anyone to bailout a government. Well, at least not with real money. Central banks have an infinite supply of funny money waiting to be created from thin air, but we will get to that in a moment.

Did you really think that the risks inherent in the economy simply vanish when the government takes them on? Nope, they're still there. In fact, you the taxpayer has taken them on.

Strangely enough, the government of choice when it comes to parking your money during dangerous times is the American one. Whenever markets tank, the American dollar and its government's bonds seem to surge. Daily Reckoning readers know we consider this to be absurd. The American government is probably worse off than many countries in the long run.

So why does the "flight to dollars" commence each time world equity markets take a step backwards in their weird dance routine? Well, it's all got to do with liquidity.

"The secondary market for U.S. Treasury securities is the most liquid secondary market in the world. The spread between bid and offer prices is usually considerably narrower than other securities, making most Treasury issues easy to purchase and sell. [Emphasis added]"

When you don't know what to do, you try to keep your options open. Treasuries earn small amounts of interest, but are easily convertible to money, even in the large quantities that some funds deal in. This gives even the biggest investor the flexibility to move fast. The thing is that these government bonds probably aren't worth holding on to for very long.

This leads to an incredible opportunity for investors. It's "a no brainer" to sell short Treasuries says Nassim Taleb on Bloomberg. "Every single human being should have that trade." Nassim's ability to forecast the crisis made him and his book "The Black Swan" a household name.

The list of people who agree with him is enormous and includes some big players. But that makes me nervous. If everyone agrees, why has nothing dramatic happened? The answer we venture is that investors don't want to get caught out investing outside of the US, just in case the flight to the dollar occurs again.

However, consider that Bernanke and his fellow counterfeiters have put in some good practice at manipulating markets. They can engineer quite a rally through their policy tools. So how does this play out?

Simply put, the Fed can support bond and other asset prices all day long, but only at the expense of the value of the US dollar. It can print money to buy US government bonds and other assets, but more money means that money is worth less - that's inflation.

The illustrious forecaster of the financial crisis, Peter Schiff, is often misunderstood. I recall a video where he refused to give his prediction for how far stock markets would fall. After much coaxing from the TV host, an answer was finally given, much to the confusion of those watching.

The answer was that the Dow (the index commonly quoted) will be worth "1 ounce of gold". This implies a significant fall in the Dow, or rise in the price of gold. What Schiff means is exactly my point above. The Dow could go anywhere if the value of the dollar changes as well. If the Dow rises by 50%, but the value of the dollar falls by 90%, you still have a whopping loss.

So, why one ounce of gold?

As gold is considered the only real money that has withstood the test of time, it is a better asset to measure the Dow against than any paper currency. Any change in the value of the dollar should occur in the value of gold, thus offsetting the instability of the dollar.

Of course, the value of gold isn't just influenced by inflation, but it remains the asset which has outlasted many other paper currencies. An ounce of gold could buy you a snazzy outfit in Roman times and can still do the same in Rome today. Its value remains. Meanwhile, the Zimbabwe dollar and the Reichsmark don't buy much at all.

Schiff may not only be right in his prediction for the Dow, but he has made it in a way that only savvy investors can understand.

The Ouzo Effect

Another possible kick in the shins for those shorting US government bonds, or the US dollar itself, would be a full blown sovereign debt crisis striking in Europe before the US, creating rally in the "safe" USA.

Nouriel Roubini, another predictor of world economic problems, has been vocal about the possibility of problems in Europe. In fact, he sees the potential for a serious shakeup of European economies: "Down the line, not this year or two years from now, we could have a breakup of the [European] monetary union."

If the UK weren't in as much, or more trouble this would bring delight to their faces. "Sound as a pound" is a favourite saying of one of my friends. Unfortunately, the PIIGS acronym may have to get a lot longer very soon.

"The problems currently faced by peripheral Europe could be a dress rehearsal for what the US and UK may face further down the road" said Jim Reid, a strategist at Deutsche Bank.

We would like to invite readers to submit their suggestion for a new acronym to include the US, UK and any other debt ravaged nations. Sadly, this will mean we won't get to use a bacon analogy going forward.

But your former Daily Reckoning Week in Review editor, Dr Alex Cowie, has pointed out something better than bacon. It's called the "Ouzo effect".

"This is where we see contagion [from Greece] pass across to the other European countries with bad balance sheets like Portugal, Italy and Spain, the so-called 'PIGS'. If this situation plays out slowly, and investors get little reassurance from the 'PIGS', then high risk assets such as mining equities may offer even better buying opportunities in coming weeks."

For the record, Ouzo is a brilliant Greek alcoholic beverage. I would recommend it over mining stocks any day.

The Business of Banking

The Australian government has announced the withdrawal of the wholesale funding guarantee it has provided for some time now. In other words, the banks are going to be on their own... More or less... To some extent...

Let me ask you a simple question. If you were a butcher, baker or candlestick maker and the government decided how many fillet mignon, cupcakes or candles you could sell, how would you feel? What if the government then decided at what price you could sell those items?

Any person operating under those constraints deserves your utmost sympathy, right? It sounds like something out of Stalin's Russia and Mao's China.

There is, in fact, a huge industry in Australia operating under those very constraints. The price it sells its goods/services at and the amount it can sell are largely set by the government. In fact, the industry operates much the same way around the world, under the same or similar crippling circumstances.

Strangely enough, that very same industry has been accused of rampant greedy capitalism and profiteering. Even more surprising is that the regulation applied to the industry isn't even decided on by the government. A private institution, unaccountable to government makes the rules.

What is the industry I'm on about?

You are probably thinking to yourself, "This plonker thinks I didn't read the sub-heading he wrote himself just a few lines ago."

That's right, I'm on about the banks. And not about any new regulations either. I'm talking about business as usual.

Banks sell money in the form of loans. Their price is the interest paid. The regulator known as the central bank sets both the supply of money and the interest rate. Banks can theoretically diverge from this, but competition effectively keeps them pinned down to whatever the central bank deems as appropriate.

In my opinion, there is no industry in the world more regulated than banking. Everyone else I can think of can control the price they sell at and how much they can offer to sell.

Of all the people!

After almost bringing the world economy to its knees and relying on government support to survive, the banks, credit ratings agencies and economists are back to telling the politicians they are stupid. Poor old Barnaby Joyce. Apparently he was being irresponsible by warning of too much debt. Hahaha. It's so ironic in so many ways.

The Labor party considers itself to represent the Aussie battler. Yet the Australian points out that "Swan [is] to resist [a] low-income wage breakout." This comes after the same newspaper reported in 2008 that "Wayne Swan will make it a "top priority" in his first budget to protect low- and middle-income earners, after a study revealed the lowest-paid fared well under his predecessor, Peter Costello." Maybe being a top priority of the government isn't so great.

Meanwhile, the guy who was supposed to warn us of instability in financial markets before his promotion to Treasury Secretary, Tim Geithner, has made himself look ridiculous. Again. He said the U.S. government "will never" lose its triple A credit rating. It is well known that one does not grow up to face reality without leaving "Never Never Land".

China's military has other ideas for the US government's borrowing plans, after being poked in the eye by the sale of US arms to Taiwan.

"Just like two people rowing a boat, if the United States first throws the strokes into chaos, then so must we.... attack by oblique means and stealthy feints... For example, we could sanction them using economic means, such as dumping some U.S. government bonds."

The Chinese government holds about US$ 790 billion of those bonds and a further US$1.95 trillion in US dollar reserves...

Nickolai Hubble
The Daily Reckoning Week in Review

VN:F [1.9.11_1134]
please wait...
Rating: 9.5/10 (4 votes cast)
VN:F [1.9.11_1134]
Rating: +3 (from 3 votes)
Is the American Government the Place to Park Your Money During Dangerous Times?, 9.5 out of 10 based on 4 ratings



P.S. to get The Daily Reckoning direct to your inbox sign up to our free e-mail newsletter or if you prefer to use RSS, subscribe to the Daily Reckoning RSS feed.

Related Articles:

  • Price-to-Earnings Ratio of the S&P 500 Index
  • Gold is the Only Place to Turn in Times of Inflation
  • China Continuing to Buy US Bonds “Every Day”
  • Dividend Drop-Off: When Cushions Turn To Rocks
  • What Inflation Means to Central Bankers, Investors and the Consumer

About the Author

Nickolai HubbleHaving recently escaped from academia, Nick decided to drop his tights (the required attire of a trapeze artist) and joined Port Phillip Publishing. Instead of telling everyone about the Daily Reckoning, he now spends his time writing for the weekend edition.

See All Posts by This Author

There Is 1 Response So Far. »

  1. Comment by Nick Marshall on 22 February 2010:

    "The regulator known as the central bank sets both the supply of money and the interest rate."

    Not true. The market sets the rate because the RBA always follows the Australian 3 month Treasury bill rate. Follow this link from Elliott Wave International to see a chart:

    http://www.elliottwave.com/freeupdates/archives/printer/2009/10/06/Illusion-of-Control-Central-Banks-and-Interest-Rates.aspx

    This begs the question - Why have a central bank? Presumably to give the illusion that the government is in control, even though the RBA is supposed to be independent. Why anyone imagines that a small group of people should have a special insight that allows them to divine the correct interest rate baffles me. It is akin to religion for most people, it seems. I am an unrepentant financial atheist and would rather pay more attention to what people do than what they are directed to do.
    Right now credit worldwide is contracting because people are saving again and banks do not want to lend. Governments are trying to prop things up by purchasing mortgage backed securities from the banks who are happy to collect the fees but do not want to add to already wonky balance sheets, but how long can they keep that up?

    VA:F [1.9.11_1134]
    please wait...
    Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.11_1134]
    Rating: +1 (from 1 vote)

Post a Response

Comment moderation policy: Port Phillip Publishing supports free speech and frank and open conversation. But we reserve the right to modify or delete your comments if we consider them to be offensive or in violation of any laws, including Australia's anti-discrimination laws

By submitting your comment you agree to adhere to our comment policy.


  • Why Should I Sign Up?   We Value Your Privacy
  • Master trader predicts next move for ASX...

    Latest Slipstream Trader Video Market Update Just In... watch for free below.


    One viewer said these prediction videos were “scarily accurate”... another said Murray Dawes was “well on the money”... To find out where the Slipstream Trader thinks the market is headed next, and what that could mean for your investments, click below now to watch his latest video update...

    8th February 2012 - Market Update

    It’s one thing to have a view on where the market is headed next... It’s another to have specific stock trading recommendations emailed to your inbox.

    To take a 90-day, no obligation trial of Slipstream Trader, click here
  • Search

    The Markets

    All Ordinaries4322.600  chart-34.500
    S&p/asx 2004245.300  chart-37.600
    China Shanghai Co2351.981  chart+2.392
    Gold Sep 110.00  chart0.00
    Clj11.nym0.00  chartN/A
    Nikkei 2258947.17  chart-55.07
    Indu0.00  chartN/A
    S&P 5001341.81  chart-10.14
    Ftse 1005858.49  chart-36.98
    2012-02-10 00:50

    Most Comments

    • Australian House Prices Are Severely and Seriously Unaffordable (312)
    • Majority of Australians Believe House Prices Will Rise in Next Twelve Months (293)
    • Gas is the New Oil (256)
    • A Date for an Aussie House Price Collapse (251)
    • How to Profit From the Path of Progress (230)

    Archives

  • Headline Archive

  • Slipstream Trader

    Thousands now trade the markets who never thought they could...

    Breakthrough in trading techniques helps regular investors:

    • Determine how much to risk in a trade
    • Lock in profits while the position is still open...
    • Exit a losing position before a share tanks...

    If you thought trading was too complicated, prepare to be surprised... click here
  • Australian Wealth Gameplan

    "A rapid contagion is spreading.
    Even if you think you are relatively safe, this is a new, permanent risk. It will be with us for the next decade, or even two”.

    - Edward Morse, Veteran oil trader

    Right now a ‘paradigm shift’ is taking place that could present you with the single biggest investment opportunity of your lifetime.

    It also represents risks to your portfolio that could surpass those of the Global Financial Crisis fallout.

    Get full details in this just-completed presentation. (turn on your speakers)
  • Diggers & Drillers

    “Why a mining executive told me to F*** Off
    in front of a whole room of investors”
    Dr. Alex Cowie doesn’t have the most popular of jobs. At least – not inside the mining industry. For his readers, it’s another matter entirely.

    As Laurence says: “I have never bought a stock and got a 100% return before … thanks for providing the information for me to have that experience – and all within two months too!”

    Right now Alex has unearthed six “must buy” resource stocks for the year ahead. His method for finding them might annoy a few people in the industry… but it could help make a lot of money in 2012 too.

    Find out why, right here

  • Home
  • Newsletters
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • Columnists
  • Contact Us
  • RSS

All content is © 2005 - 2011 Port Phillip Publishing Pty Ltd All Rights Reserved

We encourage you to republish our material, all we ask is that you provide a working text link back to the original article on this site.
Port Phillip Publishing Pty Ltd holds an Australian Financial Services License: 323 988. ACN: 117 765 009 ABN: 33 117 765 009
email: dr@dailyreckoning.com.au Tel: 1300 667 481 Fax: (03) 9558 2219
Port Phillip Publishing Attn: The Daily Reckoning PO Box 899 Braeside VIC 3195

Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Financial Services Guide

SEO Powered by Platinum SEO from Techblissonline