Consumer Spending Rising Despite Subprime Debt Crunch


We’re wondering how this fall’s shopping season is going to turn out. The subprime mortgage problem must be starting to pinch a lot of subprime families. October is the big month for adjustable rate mortgages. That is when the number of resets reaches its peak; by our calculations nearly half a million families will feel the effects that month alone. How much shopping are they going to do? We’ll find out…

Treasury Secretary Paulson says the subprime mess will not affect the rest of the economy. He must have had a lot of practice lying at Goldman Sachs (NYSE:GS) …or else it just comes naturally to him. Affecting the rest of the economy is precisely what the subprime credit debacle is doing – just as you’d expect.

At the bottom end, consumers still seem to be coping. Consumer spending is said to be going up – though, at a slower and slower rate. The little guys, like the big guys, have learned to take chances. They believe that nothing ever goes too far wrong. Whenever a correction threatens, along come the feds with more money. Worst case, they figure, the economy will turn a little soft – as it did in 2001-2002. They didn’t cut back spending then; they don’t expect to do so this time either.

On the rare occasions when we actually worry about the future…we wonder what will happen when these poor lumpenhouseholders realise what has happened to them, for they are the big losers of this economic era. Jobs and wages are moving to Asia – leaving them behind. And they actually helped finance…they helped to speed up…the process – by buying more from Asia than they could rightly afford. Now, they are the most indebted people in the world…with the most expensive lifestyles to support…and with the slowest income growth outside of Africa. While the foreigners have gotten richer and more competitive…America’s middle and lower-middle classes have merely gone deeper into debt…and added to their monthly expenses. They have bigger houses to heat and cool. They have more cars. They have more gadgets and second homes. And in the years ahead, they’ll find themselves competing with these dynamic foreigners for jobs…for earnings…for fuel…even for food – while trying to avoid bankruptcy.

At the upper end, speculators are discovering that money doesn’t always come along when you need it. The TIMES of London reports that the big banks are stuck with a half a trillion dollars’ worth of debt. The banks financed deals, expecting to sell the paper on to investors. But, suddenly, investors don’t want it.

Many deals may be “on hold” for months, says the Financial Times. Turmoil in the credit market may last for years, the paper continues. The Wall Street Journal take s up the theme with an unseasonable metaphor…the leveraged deals have “freezed” in the pipeline, says the WSJ.

Caxton Associates (JNB:CAT) sent out a letter to its nervous investors; it was combating “unfounded rumours,” it said, that its funds were in trouble. Investors in Bear Stearns’ (NYSE:BSC) two funds found that rumours concerning those funds were not unfounded at all. The funds went bankrupt. And now, the investors have gone to court, saying they were misled as to what was in them. Accredited Home Lenders Holding (NASDAQ: LEND) says it may go bankrupt. Homebuilders and lenders all over the country are running scared.

Meanwhile, many hedge funds are said to be barring investors from taking their money out; they are struggling to avoid being forced to take their assets to market. Like down-market consumers, they’re hoping to wait out this soft patch. A total of about US$1.7 trillion is supposed to be in hedge funds. Surely, a lot of it will come out…or disappear…before this downdraft in the credit markets is over. And it won’t be over for a while…most likely.

Our old friend, Jim Rogers, says the housing bubble is “one of history’s biggest bubbles”. Rogers says he’s still short investment banks and homebuilders. This thing “has a long way to go,” he believes.

Bill Bonner
The Daily Reckoning Australia

Bill Bonner

Bill Bonner

Best-selling investment author Bill Bonner is the founder and president of Agora Publishing, one of the world's most successful consumer newsletter companies. Owner of both Fleet Street Publications and MoneyWeek magazine in the UK, he is also author of the free daily e-mail The Daily Reckoning.
Bill Bonner

Latest posts by Bill Bonner (see all)


Leave a Reply

1 Comment on "Consumer Spending Rising Despite Subprime Debt Crunch"

Notify of

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
9 years 2 months ago
Reading this article is like a breath of fresh air. It has the refreshing quality of honesty. If I read one more financial media person tell me that this is a small correction before we head for higher growth usually quoting an ‘analyst’ who works for an investment bank I’ll … It is a sign of the disconnect when the ‘sub prime’ problem is described as a bunch of pesky, unreliable poor people who are causing problems for all the smart rich people by not being able to pay their $300,000 debt out of their $30,000 pa income because they… Read more »
Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to