Depression: Where Mistakes are Recognized and Corrected

Reddit

“I can’t stand it anymore. I have to say something. You act like you actually want a depression. What’s wrong with you?”

The above letter came from a dear reader who has missed the point. We are as generous and warm…as caring and sharing…as anyone outside a mental institution. We only want the best for our fellow countrymen…really.

But what is best? What’s best for the fellow who bought a house he can’t afford? Isn’t it to get out the house as soon as possible? What’s best for the fellow who didn’t save enough for his retirement? Shouldn’t he start saving as much as possible as soon as possible? And how about the banker who lent money to people who couldn’t pay it back…or the investor who put his money into projects that weren’t really very good investments? Shouldn’t they take their losses as soon as possible…and move on?

The period of time in which mistakes are recognized and corrected is called a depression. Best to get it over with.

You see, dear reader, we do not believe in the perfectibility of man and his institutions. Instead, we see material progress. Man’s machines and inventions get better. But man himself? He is what he always has been…prey to sin and folly…prone to error…and ready for a good time.

If he makes mistakes, he must correct them. If he spends more than he earns in the present, he must spend less than he earns in the future.

The Dow rose 78 points yesterday, but is still more than 200 points below its high for this rally. The euro is at $1.35 – down substantially, from its high…but still 50% above where it started. Immediately after the euro was introduced, it fell. It dropped to 88 cents. People thought it was weak and irresolute. They called it the “Esperanto currency” – referring to the artificial language invented in the 19th century and designed to unite the world. Esperanto never really caught on. People feared that the euro would never really catch on either.

But it seems to work as well as any other paper currency…at least for now. So, you see, some innovations work. Some don’t. But behind them is the old rag and bone shop of the heart… As far as we can tell, either progress of the human race is glacially slow…or there is none at all.

Even real material progress is slow. Over the last two centuries, real increases in human wealth – in the west – average out to only about 2% per year. That doesn’t leave a lot of room for error. Make a few big mistakes…such as those caused by miscues from the central banks…and you’re actually going backwards.

Are bankers really smarter, better, shrewder than they were 100 or 1,000 years ago? How about investors? Don’t they make exactly the same mistakes they always made…?

Not many humans have the luxury that we have. Here at The Daily Reckoning headquarters, we’re paid to keep our eyes open…and to try to figure out what is going on.

Of course, we’re not paid very well. Still, what a luxury it is to be able to watch… Economists on Wall Street have to answer to the big banks that employ them. Naturally, they want to show that the world is always getting better. They want their customers to buy more stocks and bonds…which will become more and more valuable, forever and ever.

And then, there are the economists working for the government. They want to prove that they can control the economy…and improve it! Otherwise, why bother to hire them?

There are other economists working for universities and colleges. What do they want to do? They want to show that they are part of the elite classes…capable of leading the country…capable of making decisions. Capable of running things. You don’t get important posts in academia by being “negative.” You don’t win the Nobel Prize in economics by saying “hey…this is all very entertaining…this economics…but there’s not really very much you can do about it.”

Here at The Daily Reckoning, on the other hand, we have no hope of getting tenure…a Nobel…or even a raise. We have no boss and no one to flatter or mislead. We answer to no one but our Dear Readers. And we don’t even pay any attention to them!

Do we want a depression? Well…yes…bring it on! But not because we enjoy seeing people lose their houses and stand in bread lines. It’s only because we know that a lot of mistakes were made during the bubble years – thanks largely to the government’s mishandling of the economy. While real, underlying wealth only grew at maybe 2% per year, people spent an extra 5% to 10%. This spending gap grew during the bubble years, effectively consuming wealth that had not been earned yet…and leading to so many capital investment mistakes that there is no way to avoid a bit of backtracking – which we recognize as a depression.

Here at The Daily Reckoning, we love depression like we love mid-winter. It clears the air…and prepares the earth for spring.

Bill Bonner
for The Daily Reckoning Australia

Bill Bonner

Bill Bonner

Best-selling investment author Bill Bonner is the founder and president of Agora Publishing, one of the world's most successful consumer newsletter companies. Owner of both Fleet Street Publications and MoneyWeek magazine in the UK, he is also author of the free daily e-mail The Daily Reckoning.
Reddit

Leave a Reply

6 Comments on "Depression: Where Mistakes are Recognized and Corrected"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
dinakarananda
Guest

Bush fires and depressions are the evil-necessities of life and economy.

john
Guest

Bill, The coming winter might turn into an iceage…. so many things have been over cooked: the world population is overblown, climate change is working up, oil production may have peaked, food production is peaking, Australian cities have all suffered water shortages and you guys correctly call peak credit. It might take more than a couple of years to sort this one out!!

Curt
Guest

Excellent article. Another way to put it is the need to visit the dentist after you have eaten too much candy. The longer you wait, the more damage will happen and more its going to cost you to get your tooth repaired and move on.

dan
Guest

Bill,
Awesome – no one to impress, flatter, please, perform for.
i don’t always agree with the DR views but i read and think about them all the same.
A world where everything is massaged to be pleasant or howled down for being unpleasant ain’t a world for me.
Life the seasons, life, death, love they all have their pros and cons.

“The soul would have no rainbow if the eyes had no tears.”
John Vance Cheney

Ross
Guest
From the report below we may be forgiven for doubting Bill’s conviction investment credentials when he recently moved to Washington ….. Or does he believe that his “Depression: Where Mistakes are Recognized and Corrected” has him locating there for an eyewitness account of unfolding events? A selected quote report on the US’s richest counties from Forbes Wealth Radiates from the Capital It’s not surprising that workers in Loudoun do well. The federal government generates a wealth of jobs, keeping unemployment in the D.C. metro area at a low 6.2% (the national average is still near 10%). The best-paid workers from… Read more »
Don
Guest
I think Bill has written before about the evolution of the economy in America and where the centre of activity was concentrated. It used to be Detroit then it moved to Wall Street and now it is moving to Washington :( This is the same reason why Canberra is no doubt a great buy in real estate – plenty of jobs being generated – hoorah what a joy to hear. Now with this so-called takeover of hospitals, what can be 100% guaranteed is – not shorter waiting lists or better service – but more bureaucrats :( and they will grow… Read more »
wpDiscuz
Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to letters@dailyreckoning.com.au