Did the Federal Reserve Just Admit That QE Doesn’t work?


Did the US Federal Reserve just admit that their long running policy of QE doesn’t work? We don’t know, but it sure seems like it.

Whenever you want a quick interpretation of what the Federal Reserve actually said or meant in one of its meetings, turn to Fed mouthpiece at the Wall Street Journal, John Hilsenrath. The following introduction says it all about the Fed’s current indecision:

Federal Reserve officials had a wide-ranging discussion about the outlook for monetary policy at their Oct. 29-30 policy meeting. The bottom line was that they stuck to the view that they might begin winding down their $85 billion-per-month bond-buying program in the “coming months” but are looking for ways to reinforce their plans to keep short-term interest rates low for a long-time after the program ends.

They struggled to build a consensus on how they would respond to a variety of different scenarios. One example: What to do if the economy didn’t improve as expected and the costs of continuing bond-buying outweighed the benefits? Another example: How to convince the public that even after bond buying ends, short-term interest rates will remain low.

It seems like it’s dawning on the Fed that QE isn’t really working its way through to the real economy. So they’re beginning to think about tapering their purchases while coming up with other ways to keep interest rates low.

What other ways are they thinking of? There aren’t many that we could see. Apparently one option is to cut the rate of interest paid on excess reserves from the current 0.25%. Right now, banks hold massive amounts of excess reserves (a direct response to QE) on which the Fed pays interest.

The thinking is that by cutting this interest rate, it will encourage banks to lend. Maybe it will, but to do so banks will have to start setting up mobile lending shops or dragging people into branches to give them a loan. Banks lend to people or corporations who request a loan. Banks don’t usually hold people at gunpoint and force them to sign up.

But even the Fed sounded lukewarm on that option, stating that:

Most participants thought that a reduction by the Board of Governors in the interest rate paid on excess reserves could be worth considering at some stage, although the benefits of such a step were generally seen as likely to be small except possibly as a signal of policy intentions.

So, in summary, the Fed wants to taper in the coming months…but it’s data dependent so may or may not happen in the coming months…and when it does they’ll replace it with something else…that they’re not quite sure of yet.

Just so you’re clear, here’s a final comment from the Fed minutes:

Participants broadly endorsed making the Committee’s communications as simple, clear, and consistent as possible, and discussed ways of doing so.

What is clear is that the hedge funds are having a ball with the gold price. It was down another US$30+ overnight. Like every other major market, we believe gold is subject to manipulation. But sometimes you just have to look at the facts and realise that ‘the nefarious banking cartel’ is not behind every down move.

Right now, evidence suggests that it’s the hedge funds pushing gold lower. They’re not dumping physical gold, they’re dumping paper gold in the form of futures contracts and short selling gold as an FX currency (which trades under the FX code of XAU).

Hedge funds represent a huge pool of global capital. They’re trend following herd runners. As a group, their performance over the past few years has been average. So when they see a market trending strongly, they go in for the kill. Gold is in a cyclical bear market (within a secular bull) so they’re jumping on the short side of the trade.

Blogger Dan Norcini follows the gold futures market closely, which is where the speculators hang out. Here’s what he had to say about the overnight price smash:

So much for quiet trading ahead of today’s release of the FOMC minutes from their last meeting! Volume had just dried up with the market killing time as the hour of the release drew near when a batch of large sell orders came out of nowhere and caught the market sleeping. The intention was to run the stops sitting down below yesterday’s lows – guess what? They got them!

The surge in volume caused a temporary halt in trading. When trading resumed, momentum based selling then entered in large size dropping gold further. It fell through $1258 which was acting as a temporary floor.

Here is another example of how hedge funds can push price by taking advantage of lulls in liquidity. I am sure some in the gold camp will once again credit this "takedown" to the big bullion banks but that is simply not the case. They continue to lift their existing short positions and add to their exposure on the long side of the market. It is hedge funds who continue to reduce long side exposure and add to their growing, and profitable, number of short positions.’

All this means at some point there will be a major short covering rally. But first, we would expect to see more selling. Then, when prices become too cheap to ignore, you’ll see a wave of new capital coming into the market to push prices much higher than where they are now. But the reality is that the hedge funds have the paper gold market by the scruff of the neck. And it wouldn’t surprise to see them take gold to a new, washout low. Stay tuned…


Greg Canavan+
for The Daily Reckoning Australia

Greg Canavan
Greg Canavan is the Managing Editor of The Daily Reckoning and is the foremost authority for retail investors on value investing in Australia. He is a former head of Australasian Research for an Australian asset-management group and has been a regular guest on CNBC, Sky Business’s The Perrett Report and Lateline Business. Greg is also the editor of Crisis & Opportunity, an investment publication designed to help investors profit from companies and stocks that are undervalued on the market. To follow Greg's financial world view more closely you can subscribe to The Daily Reckoning for free here. If you’re already a Daily Reckoning subscriber, then we recommend you also join him on Google+. It's where he shares investment research, commentary and ideas that he can't always fit into his regular Daily Reckoning emails. For more on Greg go here.

Leave a Reply

2 Comments on "Did the Federal Reserve Just Admit That QE Doesn’t work?"

Notify of

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
slewie the pi-rat
slewie the pi-rat
2 years 11 months ago
Trader Dan is a knowledgeable veteran who has respected the trend all the way down, albeit somewhat grudgingly as the dissonance flowers around us. the COTS report is a week delayed, and now is the end of the week, so the data is ~2 weeks old. we’ll get the data for last week, shortly. the FED is looking like a Jules Feiffer cartoon of a cocktail party: every FED ‘speaker’ has a little balloon overhead with ‘talk’ in it. talk. talk. talk. talk. talk. talk. talk. L0L!!! everything else is ‘noise’. if something is overheard in a Feiffer cartoon, what… Read more »
2 years 11 months ago

I’d say with limited options the Fed has control of this system as they crash it into the ground as per a controlled demolition. A new iteration of the financial matrix will be awaiting the tired and the poor.

Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to letters@dailyreckoning.com.au