Stocks bounced...just as they should have. After two weeks of falling, they were ready to bounce. Heck, even a dead congressman will bounce, if you drop him from high enough.
The Dow rose 135 points. Not very impressive, after so many down days.
Everything has been sinking...stocks, commodities, oil...
It's just like...well...a Great Correction!
And look at Facebook. We knew the Facebook IPO would cost a lot of saps a lot of money. But we didn't expect it to happen so fast. We figured Wall Street would get a chance to squeeze the lumpen a little longer before they fled the market.
As it turned out, the mum and pop investors came into the market to buy Facebook and got whacked right away.
Here's one completely un-savvy buyer quoted in The New York Post:
"I'm very psychic when it comes to stocks, I really am. I have no retirement, I have no pension, so I try to make money on the market."
The press reported that cab drivers and plumbers were buying Facebook shares on the first day...for the wrong reasons, of course. One buyer had recently had his house foreclosed. He was buying the stock, he said, to help put his children through school. Good luck on that!
Colleague Justice Litle called it 'Facebust!' The hype sent shares up in early trading on Friday. The insiders who moved fast were able to cash out at over $40. But then, the selling overpowered the buying. Justice, writing over the weekend:
Countless idiots, er, optimists expected Facebook shares to pop 50% or more on their first day of trading, not taking into account the fact that, when EVERYONE IN THE WORLD has the same universally telegraphed notion as you - with ability to execute by mashing a mouse button - it is probably not the sharpest play.
At any rate, after a very anemic "pop" reminiscent of discount bin champagne purchased from a gas station, Facebook shares fell straight to the $38 level (where the IPO was officially priced).
At $38 the underwriter investment banks came in, vigorously "defending the shares" as a matter of business honor. Without the heavy buying of Morgan Stanley and others, for the express purpose of propping up the shares, FB could have seen a death spiral on its first day of trading. This would have forever marred said underwriters' reputations, which is why it didn't happen.
(Investment banks are paid a very pretty penny for bringing an IPO to market; one of the services they provide, in exchange for that fat payday, is propping up the shares, i.e. "creating a price floor," with their own dough as need be, to keep the offering from looking like a dog. This is completely legal and sanctioned by the SEC.)
The Facebook IPO was a sort of psychological fulcrum point. It was perhaps the biggest public participation event of all time, in terms of getting "the man on the street" to take a flyer on a stock. When such tomfoolery works out badly, Joe Sixpack's taste for risk - the mother's milk of Wall Street - is that much further soured. (It should be noted that a whole raft of other "social media" stocks - Zynga etc. etc. - fell hard when Facebook came up short.)
In addition to the above, virtually every large mutual fund and long-only money manager on Wall Street felt compelled to purchase Facebook shares (for fear of missing out on "the next Apple" had they not).
If the Facebook hype fails, then - if the Maginot line of $38 price support gives way - it could have an incredibly demoralizing impact on the market as a whole, alongside the ominous "doom loop" that is Greece.
Such are the conditions in which "unease" turns to "maybe we should get out," which then has a nasty habit of escalating to "GET ME OUT NOW," acted upon by groupthink investors en masse.
And the Maginot Line gave way...
"Market Up, But Investors Dump Facebook," was the headline report from Reuters. The stock sold off...finishing the day down 11%. What happened to the underwriters, everyone wanted to know. The stock fell below the IPO price on its first full day of trading. Apparently, Wall Street was not willing to come to the rescue - not with its own money.
We had a hunch that Facebook might become the hinge event for this stock market. Shares had been selling off for two weeks prior to the FB launch. But the selling was orderly.
After so much selling for so many days, buyers are bound to come back. So the Dow went up yesterday.
But the FB hinge has creaked...and squeaked...and warned retail investors. They came in the door. They didn't like what they saw. Many will take to the exits quickly. Others will stick around, until a growing sense of revulsion, mixed with losses, eventually pushes them out.
for The Daily Reckoning Australia
From the Archives...
The Physical Gold Market - From the Weak to the Strong
2012-05-18 - Greg Canavan
Why JP Morgan is Playing the Same Old Rigged Game
2012-05-17 - Eric Fry
Why Greece Can't Afford to Stay in the Euro
2012-05-16 - Dan Denning
A Big Oops at JP Morgan!
2012-05-15 - Dan Amoss
Preparing For China's Growth Slowdown With The 'Energy Hub' Portfolio
2012-04-14 - Dan Denning
- Investing in Facebook: How to Lose Money the Easy Way
- Facebook: Don’t Fish in These Waters
- The Delusion of Regulating Risk
- The Stock Market Turns
- Were it Not for Dumb Money…
About the Author
Best-selling investment author Bill Bonner is the founder and president of Agora Publishing, one of the world's most successful consumer newsletter companies. Owner of both Fleet Street Publications and MoneyWeek magazine in the UK, he is also author of the free daily e-mail The Daily Reckoning.