These Markets Are ‘Extreme Bargains’ Right Now

stocks under watch

The big news this week was that the Fed dropped its pledge to be ‘patient’ in raising interest rates

The Fed wants to get the market used to the idea of higher rates sometime in the not so distant future. 

But just so you are clear on how valuable this ‘forward guidance’ is, Fed chief Janet Yellen later told reporters, ‘Just because we removed the word patient from the statement doesn’t mean we are going to be impatient.’

Patient and impatient are not the only possibilities. In between is a vast space in which one can get things done, but without being in a hurry about it. 

Besides, we can think of many other adjectives that far better describe Yellen’s position — fearful, ignorant, conceited, arrogant, trapped…

A gloomier outlook

Yellen will keep interest rates ultra-low not because she is patient or impatient, but because she’s afraid of what may happen if rates rise. 

She knows the outlook for the US economy is getting gloomier. It lowered its forecast for 2015 GDP growth (to between 2.3% and 2.6%). It also lowered its forecast for consumer price inflation. The Fed expects the inflation rate to slow to as low as 1.3% this year. 

What would happen to the stock market if the Fed suddenly decided to let savers earn some real yield? 

We don’t know. Neither does Janet Yellen. But Mr Market has become accustomed to free money. Like a young adult still living with his parents, he is likely to become indignant if he is suddenly asked to do his own laundry. 

And so, the mollycoddling and spoiling of the financial sector continues. The meltdown will have tost come later.

Where’s cheap now?

But last week, we promised to tell you where to find value in the investment world. We will not disappoint you. 

Long-suffering readers will know that your major investment decision is where to put your money. 

As study after study shows, asset allocation, not stock selection, is what determines most of your investment returns. 

You might also know that the market most likely to give you a healthy return going forward is the one that gave you the weakest and most disappointing returns looking backward. 

That’s because high past returns typically mean an asset has become more expensive relative to its intrinsic value. And low past returns typically mean an asset has become cheaper. 

And the idea is to buy low and sell high, not the other way around. 

Today, we put the two together, turning to an old friend who writes under the pen name Marco Polo:

We can’t know with any certainty exactly how much profit any one company or group of companies will make in future years. But we do know how the current price of a company’s shares compares with its recent finances.

Is the price high or low? To figure that out, you need to look at it from several directions.

And the winner is…

Our friend looks at the 12-month trailing price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio, the dividend yield and the price-to-book (P/B) ratio. 

Measured by P/E this indicates that Russia (6.7), Italy (8.5), China (10.1) and Greece (8.1) are cheapest and Spain (22.3), Portugal (20.6), Canada (20.6), Switzerland (20.6) and the USA (20.3) are the most expensive. 

Using dividend yield the bargains appear to be Russia (5.7%), Brazil (4.8%), Spain (4.6%) and Portugal (4.3%), and the worst yields are available in Greece (0.7%), Japan (1.7%), India (1.5%) and the USA (1.8%). 

By [the price-to-book ratio] both Greece and Russia are trading below liquidation value, both with P/Bs of 0.7. Put another way, at the end of December there was 43% upside to liquidation value in both markets (1 divided by 0.7 equals 1.43, or 143%). 

That indicates an extreme bargain in both cases. Earnings can swing around from year to year, but book values are much more stable.

Our friend also looks at the Shiller P/E (aka the CAPE ratio or P/E10). This compares today’s share price with the average of the past 10 years’ earnings after adjusting for inflation. 

By this measure there are four “cheap” markets with P/E10s less than 10. Those are Russia (4.6), Brazil (8.8), Portugal (6.3) and Greece (2.4). At the expensive end, over 20, we find India (20.3), Switzerland (23.1), Japan (25.9), Indonesia (26.6), the USA (27.8) and Italy (29.6).

Who’s the winner? 

Russia. It is cheap on all measures. It gives you the most value you can get. 

And where do you get the least value? 

Only one country is expensive on all measures,’ concludes our friend. ‘The USA.’ 

A simple investment formula: Sell the US. Buy Russia. 


Bill Bonner,
for the Daily Reckoning Australia

From the Archives…

Don’t Let Australian Stock Opportunities Pass You By
21-3-2015 by Callum Newman

Join The Daily Reckoning on Google+

Bill Bonner

Bill Bonner

Best-selling investment author Bill Bonner is the founder and president of Agora Publishing, one of the world's most successful consumer newsletter companies. Owner of both Fleet Street Publications and MoneyWeek magazine in the UK, he is also author of the free daily e-mail The Daily Reckoning.
Bill Bonner

Latest posts by Bill Bonner (see all)


Leave a Reply

2 Comments on "These Markets Are ‘Extreme Bargains’ Right Now"

Notify of

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
slewie the pi-rat
slewie the pi-rat
1 year 6 months ago
this is getting pretty funny. these calls are wonderful, and “logical”, of course, but there is not much “accountability” for the last 5 or so, just another, new “call”. this time? “sell US! buy Russia!” b/c one is “high” and another is “low”! is this an Argentinian ETF spread? what happened with the buy Russian oil stocks call? they were “low”, so: BUY! gold mining stocks were “low”, so: BUY! warnings about betting against the Dollar which was breaking out? they went unheard. then the Dollar went on a tear and these “calls” truly sucked rocks. and, they went into… Read more »
slewie the pi-rat
slewie the pi-rat
1 year 6 months ago

no, slewie did not forget Bill’s “analysis” of the PE ratios.

quoting his staunchest partners and oldest friends, Bill worked the “historical” PE analysis, “proving” stocks are overpriced!
he left out the Present Value analysis and, with the record low interest rate(s) remaining UN-factored in, generated a clear and PRESENT s.e.l.l. signal.
rates declined further.

hey! at least i’m paying attention!

Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to