A Possible Holocaust in U.S. Bonds


“U.S. financial firms have taken write downs and losses of $666.1 billion since the beginning of 2007,” according to Bloomberg. There you have it. The number of the bust.The financial end times rolled on yesterday. The latest twist is the decision of U.S. regulators to come to the aid Citigroup, the world’s largest financial services firm. The Feds stepped in to guarantee around US$306 billion of Citi’s troubled assets. In exchange, Uncle Sam gets preferred shares with an 8% dividend.

That news was enough to send the S&P 500 up 6.5% on the day. It continues Friday’s rally, and sets just the right tone for a decent day here in Australia. Whether that actually happens is something we’ll get to in a minute.

What do you make of this latest triage of the broken financial system? It keeps things ticking over. But how do you fix a nation that has too much debt by adding more debt? The U.S. government, through its various agency paramedics, is injecting money and buying equity all over the economic shop. But it’s not cheap.

Bloomberg tallied up the various commitments, loans, and guarantees made on behalf of the U.S. taxpayer by various Federal agencies and non-elected officials. It was not a small number. It came to US$7.76 trillion, a vaguely patriotic sum, echoing the year the Declaration of Independence was proclaimed in 1776.

You can read the Bloomberg article as an explication of dependence. Or better yet, a pledge of eternal subservience to the power of debt. The $7 trillion plus figure is nearly half of annual U.S. GDP. Just under half of it$3.18 trillion-is money tapped by financial firms through various auction facilities. It goes to rebuild balance sheets, rather than building factories, bridges, or new sources of power.

The Federal Reserve is the biggest instrument of this ramp up in commitments. The Fed has pledged $4.74 trillion on behalf of Americans. That’s 61% of the total amount, and $24,000 for every man, woman, and child in America (born free, but now everywhere in debt). More on this in a moment.

Here in Australia, local shares should get a boost from rising commodity prices (provided no more margin loans get called on insiders and short sellers cover). Oil was up $4.50 to $54.43 for a 9% gain on the day. Gold shot up nearly $30 to $821.90 for almost a four percent gain. Copper was up 6%, nickel 7%, zinc 6.4%, and tin 11.3%. And what, pray tell, may have led to that move?

Chinese monthly refined copper imports were up 15% in October, an eight month high. But what China gives it may also take a way. Cochilco, China’s state-run copper outfit, cut is forecast for copper prices in 2009. Where does that leave us with the base metals and with base metal shares? We asked Diggers and Drillers editor Al Robinson.

“China’s resurgent demand for raw materials is already surprising the market,” he wrote to us via e-mail from 2 metres away. “It reverted to ‘net importer’ status in all base metals for October, according to the London Metal Exchange (LME). China already needs more resources than it can get its hands on.”

“It’s buying more rock than it’s selling, in other words. That’s great news for the Australian resource sector in 2009.” Al tells the full story about Rainy Day resource stocks here.

“But this story goes further,” he adds. “China isn’t experiencing some sort of meek comeback, following the Olympic slowdown. It actually imported enough copper in October to offset the rest of the LME’s inventory rise. The ‘rest of the world’ may not be setting commodity demand ablaze. But China is already starting to fill in the gaps created by Western recession – on its own.”

While China fills the gaps, you may also start to see some short covering from traders who went short the base metals. That short covering could lead to big one day moves in the shares (which are appallingly over-sold). But it may not quite mark the bottom in metals prices. That’s going to be a function of supply and demand (with supply tightening as projects are shelved and demand idling).

The other thing to look for is bargain hunting. Investors and fund managers who liquidated long positions in the resource sector earlier this year to raise cash may begin nibbling if they find the right share at the right price. Take China for example.

Today’s Australian reports that “Rio may sell stakes to china to reduce debt.” Rio’s Chairman Paul Skinner was in Melbourne to discuss, among other things, the possibility of Rio selling assets or an equity stake to China Inc. in order to help pay off some of Rio’s US$9 billion in debt that matures in 2009. Maybe Rio should first ask the Fed before giving up equity to China. Bernanke can be pretty accommodating, we hear.

And now it is time to bring that US$7.76 trillion back into the picture and put it in the context of Australian resource equities. The Citigroup bailout deal prompted a rally in stocks and a rise in U.S. bond yields on Monday. The yield on two-year U.S. notes rose as the government auctioned another US$36 billion of them into the market.

It’s hard to believe the Citigroup deal unleashed a lot of pent up bullishness on U.S. financial stocks. It’s easier to believe that the ever-increasing supply of U.S. government bonds is prompting investors who’ve rushed into them to look around for other, more desirable assets. Chinese investors, for instance, might decide than an equity stake in Rio Tinto-with its portfolio of iron ore, coal, and other assets-is a better investment than more promises to pay by the U.S. government.

Perhaps we’ve been hasty, though, in calling the pricking of the bond bubble in the past. It could be that the U.S. dollar becomes the clear winner in the global currency wipe out currently taking place. The dollar could end up being the preferred liquid currency in which to ride out the global crisis, despite the inflationary nature of U.S. monetary and fiscal policy.

If that’s the case, then the U.S. Treasury market will continue to suck up the world’s supply of available savings and capital the way a bush fire sucks up oxygen. A fire sucking up all the oxygen in a system leads to a massive destruction of life. Hence the Greek word “holokaustos.”

According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, a holocaust is a “sacrifice consumed by fire,” or, “a thorough destruction involving extensive loss of life especially through fire.” The holocaust of the Treasuries, then, is what we’re getting at. First crowd all the world’s capital into the U.S .bond market. Then burn it up.

Smart money generally goes where it’s treated best (for yield and capital appreciation). It times of fear, what’s safe is smart. And so now the world’s investors and savers have an interesting choice: is the U.S. bond market safer than cash? Is it smart to play it safe? Or are equities safer than bonds? Or are equity stakes in projects with tangible assets better bets still, even a world with a shrinking economy?

Our guess is that the printing of the Treasuries (increasing in the supply of U.S. bonds to fund the mega bailout, fuelling the eventual inflationary fire) will gradually spook investors now and into 2009. The leading edge of bargain hunters may already be finding their way into over-sold resource stocks for refuge. And will they find it? Or will their courage end in more losses?

It wouldn’t be surprising to see big one-day gains in over-sold resource stocks in the coming months. But we reckon the real story is that investors are rethinking their long-term asset allocation and will execute a new strategy after reviewing their 2009 performance.

More cash, fewer shares. And of the money that remains in shares, it will probably be parked in long-term positions that are selling at cheap valuations, perhaps with a nice yield. Expectations will be lowered and time horizons-for equities anyway-will be lengthened. You’ll have to expect less and be willing to wait longer.

Not that being in the equity market during the most serious financial crisis since 1929 is a sure thing. We live in dangerous times. Not much is certain. But for investors, the actions taken by U.S. monetary officials are starting to lead to movements in global capital. This could signal the beginning of the bottom in commodity prices, and the beginning of bargain hunting in resource shares.

Dan Denning
for The Daily Reckoning Australia

Dan Denning
Dan Denning examines the geopolitical and economic events that can affect your investments domestically. He raises the questions you need to answer, in order to survive financially in these turbulent times.

Leave a Reply

3 Comments on "A Possible Holocaust in U.S. Bonds"

Notify of

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted

[…] demand for raw materials is already surprising the market,” said Diggers and Drillers editor Al Robinson. “It reverted to ‘net importer’ status in all base metals for October, according […]

Angel Talavera
7 years 10 months ago

Cochilco is CHILE’

Angel Talavera
7 years 10 months ago

Cochilco is CHILE’s state-run company, not China. Chile is the biggest copper producer in the world, China is the biggest consumer, so it makes sense that forecasts for copper prices come from Chile, not China.

Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to letters@dailyreckoning.com.au