The System Is Rigged — What if the Gold Price is Manipulated?
Gold go boom.
I mean, how did that happen?
Out of nowhere the yellow metal is rallying, right?
As subscribers of Rock Stock Insider know, this rally was to be expected.
They know this, because of my never-ending coverage of the shiny rock. But also because of the dozen or more experts I’ve brought right into their living rooms to tell them about it.
Of course, one of the world’s foremost authorities on gold is Jim Rickards.
He’s spent a decade explaining the metal to people. And has published five books with gold at the heart of his economic literary works.
And today he has some groundbreaking news for readers. What if the gold price is manipulated?
Well today he answers that question. And rather than conspiracy theories and web holes, he says he has the evidence to prove it is.
Read on for more…
Until next time,
How the Gold Price Is Manipulated
Is there gold price manipulation going on? Absolutely. There’s no question about it. That’s not just an opinion.
There is hard statistical evidence to make the case, in addition to anecdotal evidence and forensic evidence. The evidence is very clear, in fact.
I’ve spoken to members of Congress.
I’ve spoken to people in the intelligence community, in the defence community, very senior people at the IMF.
I don’t believe in making strong claims without strong evidence, and the evidence is all there.
I spoke to a PhD statistician who works for one of the biggest hedge funds in the world. I can’t mention the fund’s name, but it’s a household name. You’ve probably heard of it. He looked at COMEX (the primary market for gold) opening prices and COMEX closing prices for a 10-year period.
He was dumbfounded.
He said it was the most blatant case of manipulation he’d ever seen. He said if you went into the aftermarket, bought after the close and sold before the opening every day, you would make risk-free profits.
He said statistically that’s impossible unless there’s manipulation occurring…
I also spoke to Professor Rosa Abrantes-Metz at the New York University Stern School of Business. She is the leading expert on globe price manipulation. She has actually testified in gold manipulation cases.
She wrote a report reaching the same conclusions. It’s not just an opinion, it’s not just a deep, dark conspiracy theory.
Here’s a PhD statistician and a prominent market expert lawyer, expert witness in litigation qualified by the courts, who independently reached the same conclusion.
Cooking the books
How do these manipulations occur?
Currently the price of gold is set in two places.
One is the London spot market, controlled by six big banks including Goldman Sachs and JPMorgan.
The other is the New York gold futures market controlled by COMEX, which is governed by its big clearing members, also including major Western banks.
In effect, the big Western banks have a monopoly on gold prices even if they do not have a monopoly on physical gold.
The easiest way to perform paper manipulation is through COMEX futures. Rigging futures markets is child’s play.
You just wait until a little bit before the close and put in a massive sell order. By doing this, you scare the other side of the market into lowering their bid price; they back away.
That lower price then gets trumpeted around the world as the ‘price’ of gold, discouraging investors and hurting sentiment. The price decline spooks hedge funds into dumping more gold as they hit ‘stop-loss’ limits on their positions.
A self-fulfilling momentum is established where selling begets more selling, and the price spirals down for no particular reason except that someone wanted it that way.
Eventually a bottom is established and buyers step in, but by then the damage is done.
Futures have a huge amount of leverage that can easily reach 20 to 1.
For $10 million of cash margin, I can sell $200 million of paper gold.
Hedge funds are now large players in the gold market. To a hedge fund, gold may be an interesting market in which to deploy its trading style. To them, gold is just another tradable commodity. It could just as well be coffee beans, soybeans, Treasury bonds, or any other traded good.
Hedge funds use what are called ‘stop-loss’ limits. When they establish a trading position, they set a maximum amount they are willing to lose before they get out. Once that limit is reached, they automatically sell the position regardless of their long-term view of the metal.
Perhaps they don’t even have a long-term view, just a short-term trading perspective.
If a particular hedge fund wants to manipulate the gold market from the short side, all it has to do is throw in a large sell order, push gold down a certain amount, and once it hits that amount, these stops are triggered at the funds that are long gold.
Once one hedge fund hits a stop-loss price, that hedge fund automatically sells. That drives the price down more. The next hedge fund hits its stop-loss. Then it sells too, driving the price down again. Selling gathers momentum, and soon everyone is selling.
Even the banks don’t hold the gold
Another way to manipulate the price is through gold leasing and ‘unallocated forwards’.
‘Unallocated’ is one of those buzzwords in the gold market. When most large gold buyers want to buy physical gold, they’ll call JPMorgan Chase, HSBC, Citibank, or one of the large gold dealers.
They’ll put in an order for, say, $5 million worth of gold.
The bank will say fine, send us your money for the gold and we’ll offer you a written contract in a standard form. Yet if you read the contract, it says you own gold on an unallocated basis. That means you don’t have designated bars.
There’s no group of gold bars that have your name on them or specific gold bar serial numbers that are registered to you.
In practice, unallocated gold allows the bank to sell the same physical gold 10 times over to 10 different buyers.
It’s no different from any other kind of fractional reserve banking.
Banks never have as much cash on hand as they do deposits. Every depositor in a bank thinks he can walk in and get cash whenever he wants, but every banker knows the bank doesn’t have that much cash.
The bank puts the money out on loan or buys securities; banks are highly leveraged institutions.
If everyone showed up for the cash at once, there’s no way the bank could pay it. That’s why the lender of last resort, the Federal Reserve, can just print the money if need be. It’s no different in the physical gold market, except there is no gold lender of last resort.
Banks sell more gold than they have. If every holder of unallocated gold showed up all at once and said, ‘please give me my gold,’ there wouldn’t be nearly enough to go around. Yet people don’t want the physical gold for the most part.
There are risks involved, storage costs, transportation costs, and insurance costs. They’re happy to leave it in the bank. What they may not realise is that the bank doesn’t actually have it either.
Gold holders should expect these games to continue until a fundamental development drives the price to a permanently higher plateau.
The long run matters more
How does the individual investor stand up against such forces?
In the short run, you can’t beat them, but in the long run, you always will, because these manipulations have a finite life.
Eventually the manipulators run out of physical gold, or a change in inflation expectations leads to price surges even governments cannot control. There is an endgame.
History shows manipulations can last for a long time yet always fail in the end.
They failed in the 1960s London Gold Pool, with the United States dumping in the late 1970s, and the central bank dumping in the 1990s and early 2000s.
The gold price went relentlessly higher from US$35 per ounce in 1968 when the London Gold Pool failed to US$1,900 per ounce in 2011, the all-time high.
Price manipulation always fails.
And the US dollar price of gold will resume its march higher. The other weakness in the manipulation schemes appears in the use of paper gold through leasing, hedge funds, and unallocated gold forwards.
These techniques are powerful.
Still, any manipulation requires some physical gold.
It may not be a lot, perhaps less than 1% of all the paper transactions, yet some physical gold is needed.
The physical gold is also rapidly disappearing as more countries are buying it up. That puts a limit on the amount of paper gold transactions that can be implemented.
My suggestion to investors is that it’s important to understand the dynamics behind gold pricing.
Understanding these dynamics lets you see the endgame more clearly and supports the rationale for owning gold even when short-term price movements are adverse.
Gold will win in the end.
All the best,
PS: Discover how some investors are preserving their wealth and even making a profit, as the economy tanks. Download your FREE report by clicking here.